Hussman: A Mixed Bag of Market Conditions

John Hussman is very good this week and remember he wrote this early monday before the tuesday and wednesday action.

A Mixed Bag of Market Conditions

t's instructive that the total return of the S&P 500 over the past 4 years has now averaged just 5.7% annually, despite the fact that the recent decline is still well short of a minimal bear market. The return on the S&P is close enough to the return on risk-free Treasury bills that our hedging over this entire period has cost us close to nothing. Equally instructive is that the S&P 500 has now lagged Treasury bills since April 1998. Valuations do indeed drive long-term market returns.

The recent bull market began at the highest valuations of any prior bull market in history. It has predictably achieved below-average overall returns, and the cycle isn't even over yet. Though every market cycle is different, an “average” bull market represents a span of about 3.75 years, with total returns averaging about 27% annually, followed by a bear market of about 1.25 years, with total returns averaging about -27% annually. That means that, on average, a typical bear market loss of just over 30% has shaved a typical bull market gain of 145% down to a cumulative return of about 65% (for a full cycle of about 5 years and overall annual total returns of about 10.6%).