Showing posts with label protectionism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label protectionism. Show all posts

Friday, January 30, 2009

Is Obama showing his true colors? I hope not.

I have been giving the President the traditional honeymoon because I legitamately wish him well. I would wish any new President well but Obama bears the extra weight of being the first black president and it is important he succeeds.
This past week has raised my hackles. The administration repeatedly spews protectionist rhetoric. The democratic party is sponsoring a dangerously irresponsible bill taking the secret ballot away from labor elections depriving all workers of any privacy in expressing his or her views. The only reason to disallow secret ballot is to be able to exert pressure on those who do not support leadership. As a thought experiment imagine the democrats reaction had President Bush advocated doing away with the secret ballot in presidential elections. This bill is a travesty, if union members support this they are cutting their own throats.
The stimulus was going to be about infrastructure and tax reduction because they were badly needed in the first case and have a quick effect in the second. Instead Pelosi gives us a relatively small infrastructure plan and a potpourri of political pork. Money for the endowment for the arts is popular in San franccisco, no doubt, but it stimulates nothing but the evening gown and cocktail wiener industries. The bill is an orgy of traditional vote buying, not a job creation plan.
Obama should encourage his own party to kill the bill and demand Pelosi step down in favor of someone competent. In fact someone just not up to the job would be an improvement.
I hope all these stumbles are just part of finding his footing as a new president. if not Mr. Obama will have revealed himself as Jimmy Carter and we will all have learned at very great cost that community activist is not sufficient excutive experience for the most important job in the world.

Right now Mr Obama is behaving like the far left liberal that ran against Hillary Clinton and not like the centrist who defeated Senator McCain and nothing like the president elect we saw for two months. President Obama needs to recenter and soon. I wish him success but I am using tight stops.

Update: Related article from David Brooks at the NYT

In a fateful decision, Democratic leaders merged the temporary stimulus measure with their permanent domestic agenda — including big increases for Pell Grants, alternative energy subsidies and health and entitlement spending. The resulting package is part temporary and part permanent, part timely and part untimely, part targeted and part untargeted.

It’s easy to see why Democrats decided to do this. They could rush through permanent policies they believe in. Plus, they could pay for them with borrowed money. By putting a little of everything in the stimulus package, they avoid the pay-as-you-go rules that might otherwise apply to recurring costs.

But they’ve created a sprawling, undisciplined smorgasbord, which has spun off a series of unintended consequences. First, by trying to do everything all it once, the bill does nothing well. The money spent on long-term domestic programs means there may not be enough to jolt the economy now (about $290 billion in spending is pushed off into 2011 and later). The money spent on stimulus, meanwhile, means there’s not enough to truly reform domestic programs like health technology, schools and infrastructure. The measure mostly pumps more money into old arrangements.
Click here to read the rest

Thursday, January 29, 2009

Second example of protectionism from Democrats in 9 days

Barack Obama took office on January 20 and we have had two instances of protectionist action already. First was Geithner's China currency manipulation comments, and now legislation mandating steel used in infrastructure spending be made in the U.S. I undeerstand the motivations behind these moves but they are playing with fire. Mr. Smoot and Mr.Hawley thought they were being reasonable too. Obama better find a waay to get real leadership in Congress because Pelosi and Reid are hacks that will hold President Obama down like anchors.

From Reuters:
U.S. House approves 'Buy America' steel measure

WASHINGTON, Jan 28 (Reuters) - The U.S. House of Representatives
on Wednesday approved a controversial "Buy
America" steel provision as part of an $825 billion package
to help pull the U.S. economy out of recession. The provision
requires public works projects funded by the bill to use
only U.S.-made iron and steel.
House leaders included the language despite strong objections
from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and other business
groups which said it would set a bad example for
other countries considering their own economic stimulus
plans.

Sunday, March 30, 2008

The Economist: how to Smite Smoot

No one running for national office seems to support free trade anymore and this is very dangerous for the U.S. and world economies. The Economist addresses this citing an new study which discusses the enormous costs of protectionism and the bounties from a combination of free trade and more immigration. ( legal immigration)

How to smite Smoot

Mar 27th 2008
From The Economist print edition

Gains from immigration could be even greater than those from more trade


IN JUNE 1930 the Smoot-Hawley tariff act turned a stockmarket collapse into a crippling, decade-long Depression. Now, politicians seem to be preparing for protectionism even while financial meltdown is going on. Barack Obama and Hillary Clinton vie with each other to be nasty about the North American Free-Trade Agreement. Last year the European Union dropped the principle of “free and undistorted competition” from its Lisbon treaty.

All the more reason, then, to welcome a study* by two eminent trade economists, Kym Anderson of the University of Adelaide and Alan Winters of the University of Sussex. They estimate the losses from such protectionism as already exists; calculate the potential gains that might accrue if—a big if—protectionist temptations were ignored and, more intriguingly, estimate the possible benefits if further migration were encouraged as well.

and continuing:

The authors show that if you use more realistic assumptions, estimates of the cost of protection actually rise from anywhere between $460 billion a year to over $2.5 trillion. (The wide range is the result of using “computable general-equilibrium models”, which are only as good as the assumptions you feed into them.) Whatever the exact amount, these are large sums and far greater than once-fashionable alternatives, such as bilateral deals.

But more trade in goods is only part of economic liberalisation. Another is trade in “factors of production”—like labour. The authors look at what might happen if the share of foreign workers grew to 3% of the labour force of rich countries. This would involve an increase, they say, of 14m people over 25 years (roughly 500,000 a year). The global gains, the authors reckon, would be $675 billion a year by 2025. Even if you subtract the cost of moving to the host country for immigrants and the social-welfare benefits they may get when they arrive, the net benefits are at least twice as much as a Doha agreement (and could be reaped by rich countries unilaterally, if they wanted).

Note these numbers start from where we are now and don't include the costs that further protectionsism being proposed by Clinton, Obama, Schumer, Graham and others pandering to ingnorant populism.

Related link: Free trade benefits

Thursday, July 5, 2007

Not all good news in China

Chinese exports to the United States aren't the only contaminated goods they are selling. David Barboza of The New York Times reports:
SHANGHAI, July 4 — China said on Wednesday that nearly a fifth of the food and consumer products that it checked in a nationwide survey this year were found to be substandard or tainted, underscoring the risk faced by its own consumers even as the country’s exports come under greater scrutiny overseas.
Many years ago Japan went through the growing pains of a reputation for cheap shoddy goods and rather deftly handled the change over to quality. It will be interesting to see how the Chinese handle this situation. it will also be interesting to see how the protectionsist voices among our elected imbeciles try to use this issue to their own advantage.